Administrative State
The Administrative State is known as the Headless Fourth Branch of the United States Government. Expansion of the Administrative State has lead to concerns about violations of the separation of powers.
INS v. Chadha, described these concerns as follows: “Functionally, [separation of powers] may be violated in two ways.
One branch may interfere impermissibly with the other’s performance of its constitutionally assigned function.
Alternatively, the doctrine may be violated when one branch assumes a function that more properly is entrusted to another.” These approaches are not neatly cabined; they can and do appear in any given case.
Mistretta v. United States (1989) (Court found that the Judicial Sentencing Commission did not violate the Separation of Powers principle as it did not lead to an excessive amount of legislative power granted to the commission, this is partly because the commission created guidelines, not laws. It also contained a rational principle dictated by Congress which the sentencing commission was directed to be guided by. The petitioner argued that there was too much power placed in the judiciary, that being the power to create laws or rules, and that it undermined the independence of the judges who sit on the commission (three federal judges were appointed to the commission).
Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (This is an example of a double delegation, where Congress delegates power to the FTC who then delegates authority to a private organization to create and adjudicate the rules of Horseracing.)
Morrison v. Olsen (Court decided that investment in independent counsel does not aggrandize or encroach on executive power, stating that it was constitutional to do so. It is questionable whether it is still good law post Trump v. Slaughter).