Earnest Work

Civil Procedure Erie Doctrine Rule

Issue

When should a federal court apply state law?

General Rule

Erie Decision Tree

Erie Decision Tree

Federal Preemption

Is there Federal Law on Point?

If there is a federal law that preempts the state rule, then the court shall apply the federal law.

Bound up in State Obligations

Is the federal law a substantive state right?

Modified Outcome-Determinative Test

Does the use of Federal law encourage forum shopping and does the use of Federal law cause an inequitable administration of the laws? If yes to either, use of State law is supported. Hanna

If the application of a federal law is not determinative of the outcome, then the court may adhere to the federal law.

If use of State law overrides a systematic federal interest, then use of Federal law is supported. Byrd

#Civil Procedure