Civil Procedure: Jurisdiction Rules
Issue
When does a court have Jurisdiction over parties involved in a claim? When is Venue Appropriate?
General Rule
There must be Adequate Notice served upon the parties involved in the lawsuit. A party without adequate notice is not subject to the ruling of a court.
Jurisdiction requires that the elements of Personal Jurisdiction and Subject Matter Jurisdiction are met.
Personal Jurisdiction can be established under two categories: General Jurisdiction (GJ) and Specific Jurisdiction (SJ).
Subject Matter Jurisdiction can be established either through a Federal Question or through a statute which provides a court with SMJ over a claim. An example of statute derived SMJ would be the Diversity Statutes (28 USC s. 1331 and 1332).
If a court is found to have jurisdiction, it must determine if venue is appropriate. The court is charged with determining whether the venue creates an unequal advantage among the opposing parties.
If the parties have received adequate notice, the court has PJ and SMJ over the issue, and the venue is appropriate, then the case may proceed in the court.
Notice Rule
Constitutional Requirement
The constitutional requirement for Notice is that the notice be reasonably calculated and that it affords a reasonable amount of time for the served party to formulate a response
Federal Rules of Service
R. 4 contains the federal requirements of notice to achieve this constitutional requirement, but the rule may be altered in state courts if the constitutional requirement may be met by other means.
If a party does not receive adequate notice of the suit against it, it will not be bound to the decision of the court. A party must have a full and fair opportunity to litigate claims against it.
PJ Rule
Personal Jurisdiction can be determined through either General Jurisdiction or Specific Jurisdiction.
General Jurisdiction
GJ over an Individual
For a court to have GJ over an individual, the court must determine whether
- The individual is domiciled within the jurisdiction (In Personam) or the property, which is the subject of the suit, must be attached to the claim at the beginning of the proceeding (In Rem). or
Domicile requires a physical presence within the jurisdiction and animus manendi (the intent to remain)
- The individual is served notice while physically present within the jurisdiction (tag jurisdiction).
GJ over a Corporation
For a court to have GJ over a corporation, the court must determine whether
The corporation is Incorporated within the jurisdiction. or
The corporation has connections within the jurisdiction which are such to render the corporation at home in that jurisdiction (Principal Place of Business). In other words, the nerve center of the corporation.
Specific Jurisdiction
Long Arm Statute
A court may exercise specific jurisdiction over an individual or entity if they perform acts enumerated in a statute which allows for the court to exercise personal jurisdiction over them
Minimum Contacts
A court may exercise SJ over a party if the following elements are met
- Purposeful Availment
The defendant intended to and did receive benefits from acts performed within the state (Targeting).
- Relatedness
The injury claimed by the plaintiff arises out of or relates to the contacts between the defendant and the state.
- Reasonableness
The court, by exercising personal jurisdiction, does not trample on notions of Fair Play and Substantive Justice.
Consent
A party may consent to a court having PJ over them in relation to conflicts regarding a contract, if the contract states that the court will have PJ over claims resulting from those conflicts.
SMJ Rule
Courts of General Jurisdiction
Trial courts have the ability to hear claims from parties over which they have General Jurisdiction, even if the injury did not occur within the state. This is limited by requirements that certain cases and controversies be heard by specific courts.
Federal Question
Federal courts have the ability to hear and decide questions of federal law. To determine if a question of federal law is raised, the court utilizes the Creation Test when determining if a federal question is present, which asks
Does a constitutional right give the plaintiff a right to sue? or
Does a federal law give the plaintiff a right to sue?
If yes to either of these questions, then a federal court has SMJ over the claim.
Diversity Jurisdiction
Diversity jurisdiction is created by statutes 28 USC s 1331 and 1332, which require that
There be complete diversity among the opposing parties, meaning that the parties must be from different states on both sides of the "v". and
The amount in damages must be reasonably calculated to exceed $75k.
In order for a federal court to hear a state-claim.
The court will examine domicile for individuals, Place of Incorporation and PPB for Corporations, and Nerve Center and Residence of Members for LLCs and LLPs when analyzing a diversity question.
Supplemental Jurisdiction
This applies to instances when state claims are tied up with a federal claim. The Grable Factors are used to determine whether the federal court may hear and decide on questions of state law. The factors are the following;
Necessarily raises a question of federal law that is essential to the state law claim (Common Core of Operative Fact).
The state claims are Actually Disputed (Genuine Disagreement)
The Federal Question is Substantial (Important to Federal System)
No disruption to principles of Federalism (Novel State Law which Feds are not adequately positioned to decide)
Venue
28 USC s 1391 creates the decision tree for analyzing whether Venue is appropriate;
A judicial district in which any defendant resides, if all defendants are residents of the State in which the district is located
A judicial district in which a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or
If there is no district in which an action may otherwise be brought as provided in this section, any judicial district in which any defendant is subject to the court's personal jurisdiction with respect to such action.
In instances where foreign jurisdiction is present, the court may also ask if there is a minimally adequate remedy in the foreign jurisdiction. If not, the factor weighs in favor of accepting venue in the US forum with jurisdiction over the claim.
Residency, not domicile, is the factor to examine when analyzing venue.
A natural person is thought to reside in the place they are domiciled
An entity defendant is thought to reside in any place which a court may exercise personal jurisdiction over them
An entity plaintiff is thought to reside where its Principal Place of Business is located.