Concurrent Jurisdiction: Removal and Remand
Concurrent Jurisdiction exists when two or more courts have jurisdiction over the same claim or controversy. When there is Concurrent Jurisdiction, removal is allowed according to specific rules.
The basic text of removal is contained in 28 USC s 1441. It allows Defendants to transfer a case to federal court, trumping a plaintiff's choice to bring a case in state court. This can only happen when the matter can be heard in both state and federal courts.
The procedure for removal is set forth in 28 USC s 1446. Challenging removal is contained in s 1447.
Keller Logistics v. Navistar, Inc. (Congress has placed a one-year “statute of limitations” on removal petitions in diversity cases—even in cases like Caterpillar, where the basis for removal did not present itself until after that date (see §1446©)—but allows removal even after a year if the plaintiff has acted in “bad faith” to block removal.)
Bad faith can manifest when a plaintiff maintains a non-diverse defendant in a case in an attempt to keep the case in state court.
A defendant is permitted to remove a case from state to federal court within thirty days of a case becomming removeable, so long as the removal does not occur more than one year after concealment of the action for cases where removal is based on diversity jurisdiction.
However, if the district court finds taht the plaintiff had acted in bad faith, that is knowingly keeping a nondiverse defendant to keep the case in the state court, there is an exception to the one year limit on removal.