Issue Preclusion
What is Issue Preclusion?
This principle bars certain issues from relitigation if those issues had been actually litigated and determined. This applies to subsequent claims involving the same transaction if they involve the same party or if they involve different parties. If different parties are involved, it is up to the judge to determine if issue preclusion is acceptable.
Defensive Issue Preclusion
A defendant seeks to preclude an issue that a plaintiff had previously litigated and lost against another defendant. Blonder-Tongue case.
It serves as incentive for the plaintiff to join all possible parties in his or her initial claim.
Offensive Issue Preclusion
a plaintiff seeks to estop a defendant from relitigating the issues which the defendant previously litigated and lost against another plaintiff.Illinois Gulf RR case.
This provides incentive for a defendant to settle a case if an issue is likely to be ruled adversely to his or her interests.
Mutuality and Issue Preclusion
Mutuality used to be required in Issue Preclusion. This was done away with in the Illinois Gulf RR case. In its place, the court is instructed to generally allow offensive issue preclusion, but to act within its discretion in denying offensive issue preclusion if the following elements are present;
The plaintiff could have easily joined the earlier plaintiff in his or her initial action.
Issue preclusion would be unfair to the defendant because;
The defendant had little incentive to defend vigorously if the initial claim was nominal
If there are inconsistencies in ruling on the issue in past cases.
If the second action affords the defendant procedural opportunities not present in past action.
If it is otherwise unfair to the defendant.