Joinder of Claims
What is Joinder of Claims?
It is a feature of modern civil litigation which allows a plaintiff to add claims to a complaint. A plaintiff may include as many independent or alternative claims against an opposing party (Unrestricted Joinder). These claims do not need to arise out of the same transaction or occurrence. If in federal court, each claim must meet Subject Matter or Supplemental Jurisdiction (refer to 28 USC s. 1367) requirements. While R. 18 permits the addition of claims arising out of separate transactions, it does not require it.
R. 13 allows for and sometimes requires that defendants assert claims against a plaintiff which arise out of the transaction which caused the suit. The rule has two kinds of joinder, permissive and compulsory. Counterclaims and Cross Claims must arise out of the same transaction as the anchor claim.
R. 18 allows a party to a claim to add on as many claims, counterclaims, cross claims, and third party claims as one desires. One may also add as many parties as possible to a claim. This rule allows for broad joinder alongside some limiting principles created by jurisdiction and due process requirements.
R. 20 states how a party, either plaintiff or defendant, may join another party if they have a right to relief or if they are jointly and severally liable alongside a defendant.
Compulsory counterclaims fall under the supplemental jurisdiction of federal courts because one is forced to bring them or waive recovery on the issue.
If the defendant’s claim is independent of the plaintiff’s claim, then the defendant has the option of bringing it in a separate suit or of asserting it under Rule 13(b) as a permissive counterclaim. In contrast to compulsory counterclaims, permissive counterclaims must either be supported by independent grounds of federal jurisdiction or fall within the supplemental jurisdiction of the court under 28 U.S.C. §1367.
Cordero v. Voltaire, LLC, 2013 WL 6415667 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 6, 2013)
This case involves a suit against an employer relating to unfair labor practices, which falls under federal jurisdiction. The employer then made a counterclaim against the plaintiffs, claiming fraud, theft, conversion and breach of fiduciary duties. The plaintiffs looked for a dismissal for lack of SMJ because the counterclaims were permissive and therefore did not fall under federal SMJ.
The court stated that the analysis required for permissive counterclaims asks 1) is there sufficient grounds for federal SMJ? and if not
- do the claims meet the test for supplemental jurisdiction under 1367(a)? If no to both, then the claim should be dismissed for lack of Jurisdiction.