Joinder of Parties
“Under the Rules, the impulse is toward entertaining the broadest possible scope of action consistent with fairness to the parties; joinder of claims, parties and remedies is strongly encouraged.” United Mine Workers of America v. Gibbs, 383 U.S. 715 (1966).
Rule 20 of the FRCP
The rule imposes two specific requisites to the joinder of parties:
- a right to relief must be asserted by, or against, each plaintiff or defendant relating to or arising out of the same transaction or occurrence, or series of transactions or occurrences; and
- some question of law or fact common to all the parties must arise in the action.
Neither a plaintiff nor a defendant need be interested in obtaining or defending against all the relief demanded. The court may grant judgment to one or more plaintiffs according to their rights, and against one or more defendants according to their liabilities.
The court may issue orders—including an order for separate trials—to protect a party against embarrassment, delay, expense, or other prejudice that arises from including a person against whom the party asserts no claim and who asserts no claim against the party.
What is a Transaction under R. 20?
The federal courts have interpreted the "same transaction or occurrence" language to be flexible. It is depending on the logical relationship. All logically related events are considered to be one part of the same transaction or occurrence. Absolute identity of events is not required.
What is a Common Issue of law and fact?
The rule does not require that all questions of law or fact be common. The right to relief depends on the ability to determine that the conduct of the defendant is basic to each plaintiff's injury.
Mosley v. General Motors Corp., 497 F.2d 1330 (8th Cir. 1974)
"the plaintiffs have asserted a right to relief arising out of the same transactions or occurrences. Each of the ten plaintiffs alleged that he had been injured by the same general policy of discrimination on the part of General Motors and the Union. Since a “state-wide system designed to enforce the registration laws in a way that would inevitably deprive colored people of the right to vote” was determined to arise out of the same series of transactions or occurrences, we conclude that a company-wide policy purportedly designed to discriminate against blacks in employment similarly arises out of the same series of transactions or occurrences. Thus the plaintiffs meet the first requisite for joinder under Rule 20(a)."
"The right to relief here depends on the ability to demonstrate that each of the plaintiffs was wronged by racially discriminatory policies on the part of the defendants General Motors and the Union. The discriminatory character of the defendants’ conduct is thus basic to each plaintiff’s recovery. The fact that each plaintiff may have suffered different effects from the alleged discrimination is immaterial for the purposes of determining the common question of law or fact. Thus, we conclude that the second requisite for joinder under Rule 20(a) is also met by the complaint."
United States v. Mississippi, 380 U.S. 128 (1965),
A suit brought by the United States against the State of Mississippi, the election commissioners, and six voting registrars of the State, charging them with engaging in acts and practices hampering and destroying the right of black citizens of Mississippi to vote. The district court concluded that the complaint improperly attempted to hold the six county registrars jointly liable for what amounted to nothing more than individual torts committed by them separately against separate applicants. The Supreme Court reversed because the defendants were all engaging in the same policy which led to the discrimination.
Henderson v. AT&T Corp., 918 F. Supp. 1059, 1061 (S.D. Tex. 1996).
The court in this case allowed joinder but severed the claims pursuant to FRCP R. 42 because it would be unwieldy to handle all claims in a single trial.