Earnest Work

Justiciability

Is a case or controversy appropriate to be heard?

Standing’s irreducible constitutional minimum requires

Injury-in-Fact

An injury must be Actual and Imminent not conjectural or hypothetical.

Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife (2006) (The Court ruled that the injury experienced by the plaintiff was not one which was actual or imminent, because the plaintiffs were claiming that the projects in a foreign country would prevent them from viewing an endangered species that they might travel to see in the future. This was too hypothetical an injury for the court to find standing)

*Lyons v. City of Los Angeles (1983) (The imminence aspect is required to have standing. Attempting to secure an injunction against an action will not occur unless petitioner can prove that the injury is imminent in the future. In this instance, the petitioner could not prove that he or other faced an imminent threat of an illegal choke hold by a police officer in the future)

Organizational Standing

An organization may bring a case if the organization itself has experienced a qualifying injury/imminent threat of injury or if one of its members has experienced a qualifying injury or threat of injury.

Third-Party Standing

!!!!

Other Cases Relating to Standing

TransUnion, LLC v. Ramirez (Violation of rights must impact the petitioner in a personal and tangible way)

Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins (Bare procedural violations divorced of any concrete harm are not sufficient to trigger standing).

Sierra Club v. Morton (Aesthetic Injury is recognized by the court.)

Allen v. Wright (The injury must be specific to the party making the claim.)

Ripeness and Mootness

Ripeness seeks to ensure that the litigation occurs at the right time—that the injury alleged has occurred or is very likely to occur. Only when injury has not yet occurred is ripeness an issue.

For a case to be ripe, the plaintiff must: Have already suffered harm; Be faced with a specific, present objective harm; or Be under threat of specific future harm.

Just as the Court has traditionally refrained from issuing advisory opinions, it also declines to reach the merits of cases that no longer present live controversies—that are, in other words, moot.

the Court has created an exception to the mootness doctrine for cases that are “capable of repetition yet evading review.”

What makes a Question/Controversy Political?

A textually demonstrable constitutional commitment of the issue to one of the political branches of the federal government

Baker v. Carr (1962)

This case laid out the factors to determine if there is a Political Question

Nixon v. United States (1993)

This case involved a question of what constitutes a "trial review of the Senate’s “trial” would introduce the same risk of bias as would participation in the trial itself. Second, judicial review would be inconsistent with the Framers’ insistence that our system be one of checks and balances. It is best if Congress handles the impeachment aspect and the Judiciary handles the criminal trial.

Partisan Political Gerrymandering

Davis v. Bandemer (1986)

Indiana Democrats challenged the reapportionment of the districts in Indiana and showed that depsite winning a majority of the votes in the state, they did not win a majority of the seats in the state's congress.

Vieth v. Jubilere (2004)

in favor of the appellees that the alleged political gerrymandering was not unconstitutional. Subsequent to the ruling, partisan bias in redistricting increased dramatically in the 2010 redistricting round.

Rucho v. Common Cause (2019)

The Court ruled that while partisan gerrymandering may be "incompatible with democratic principles", the federal courts cannot review such allegations, as they present non justiciable political question outside the jurisdiction of these courts.

Foreign Affair Questions

Goldwater v. Carter (1979)

Senator Barry Goldwater and other senators sued Jimmy Carter for unilaterally nullifying a treaty made with Nationalist China in order to open relations with communist China. The senators claimed that Carter acted outside of his power by failing to receive Senate approval to do it. The court found that this was a political question because;

#Constitutional Law #Judiciary #Justiciability