Earnest Work

Necessary and Proper Clause

Congress is granted the ability to make laws which areNecessary and Proper to carry out its enumerated powers.

The meaning of "Necessary and Proper" was a key point of contention for the court in McCulloch v. Maryland (1819).

McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)

McCulloch established the following constitutional principles;

The court found that it was necessary and proper for Congress to charter the Second Bank of the United States, and that Maryland was not permitted to tax the Baltimore branch of the bank in a way that was not consistent with other banks in the state. It was doing so as the state did not want to pay taxes to the Federal Bank.

Lambert v. Yellowley (1926) (Court found that it was necessary and proper to pass legislation that prevents a doctor from prescribing alcoholic medicine over the amount allowed by the prohibition act.)

United States v. Comstock (2010)

The court used five considerations to determine that Congress' action was necessary and proper.

  1. The Necessary and Proper Clause grants Congress broad power to enact laws that are "rationally related" and "reasonably adapted" to executing the other enumerated powers.

  2. The statute at issue "constitutes a modest addition" to related statutes that have existed for many decades.

  3. The statute in question reasonably extends the longstanding policy to cover the mentally ill and sexually dangerous persons already in federal custody.

  4. The statute properly accounts for state interests by ending the federal government's role "with respect to an individual covered by the statute" whenever a state requests.

  5. The statute is narrowly tailored to address only the legitimate federal interest.

Court found that it was necessary and proper for the Congress to establish a post-conviction civil commitment scheme pursuant to them Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act.

#Constitutional Law #Enumerated Powers #Legislative