Earnest Work

Powers of Executive

What is Executive Power?

It is the power granted to he President, but has a vague description. There are specific powers granted to the President like pardons, vetoes, and treaty negotiation. However, the most important Presidential powers are not well defined. Namely, the enforcement power.

The President is charged with the power to "take care that the Laws are to be faithfully executed." The idea that a President may act without legislative approval so long as he or she did so wihtout violating the constitution has not been fully accepted or rejected. In Domestic affairs, the power of a President to act is mroe restricted.

In Domestic executive action, the President must be acting on a power stemming from either Congress or the Constitution itself. Presidents may contend that they may act without relation to those powers, if the action stems from an aggregation of the powers granted to the office in the constitution.

An Excerpt of Justice Jackson's Concurring Opinion in Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co.

We may well begin by a somewhat over-simplified grouping of practical situations in which a President may doubt, or others may challenge, his powers, and by distinguishing roughly the legal consequences of this factor of relativity.

  1. When the President acts pursuant to an express or implied authorization of Congress, his authority is at its maximum, for it includes all that he possesses in his own right plus all that Congress can delegate. In these circumstances, and in these only, may he be said (for what it may be worth) to personify the federal sovereignty. If his act is held unconstitutional under these circumstances, it usually means that the Federal Government as an undivided whole lacks power. A seizure executed by the President pursuant to an Act of Congress would be supported by the strongest of presumptions and the widest latitude of judicial interpretation, and the burden of persuasion would rest heavily upon any who might attack it.

  2. When the President acts in absence of either a congressional grant or denial of authority, he can only rely upon his own independent powers, but there is a zone of twilight in which he and Congress may have concurrent authority, or in which its distribution is uncertain. Therefore, congressional inertia, indifference or quiescence may sometimes, at least as a practical matter, enable, if not invite, measures on independent presidential responsibility. In this area, any actual test of power is likely to depend on the imperatives of events and contemporary imponderables rather than on abstract theories of law.

  3. When the President takes measures incompatible with the expressed or implied will of Congress, his power is at its lowest ebb, for then he can rely only upon his own constitutional powers minus any constitutional powers of Congress over the matter. Courts can sustain exclusive presidential control in such a case only by disabling the Congress from acting upon the subject. Presidential claim to a power at once so conclusive and preclusive must be scrutinized with caution, for what is at stake is the equilibrium established by our constitutional system.

Analyzing a Youngstown Question

  1. How directive is the wording of the statute?

Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer (The Steel Seizure Case) 43 U.S. 579 (1952)

The accretion of dangerous power does not come in a day. It does come, however slowly, from the generative force of unchecked disregard of the restrictions that fence in even the most disinterested assertion of authority.

In this case, President Truman attempted to take control of the steel industry in the country after there was a labor dispute which threatened the production of steel. This occurred at the height of the Korean War. The court found that there were no Congressional acts granting the President the power to do this, nor did any powers granted to the President justify this action. In addition, the court stated that the Constitution supports a finding that Congress has sole legislative power in the government. Emergency does not create Executive Power!

"The Founders of this Nation entrusted the lawmaking power to the Congress alone in both good and bad times. It would do no good to recall the historical events, the fears of power and the hopes for freedom that lay behind their choice. Such a review would but confirm our holding that this seizure order cannot stand."

Removal Power

The Constitution provides for the removal of federal officers by impeachment, but it is unclear about other methods of removing federal officers, even though that is an avenue.

In Myers v. United States, 272 U.S. 52 (1926), the Court struck down a law requiring Senate approval for removal of certain postmasters. This precedent has been withered down, making it more difficult for the President to remove officers in quasi-legislative and quasi-judicial agencies, like the Federal Trade Commission. Humphrey's Executor v. United States, 295 U.S. 602 (1935).

under Myers, the President must have absolute discretion to discharge “purely” executive officials at will. Quasi-Judicial or Quasi-Legislative positions fall under the precedent set by Humphrey's Executor

In Free Enterprise Fund v. Public Company Accounting and Oversight Board, 561 U.S. 477 (2010), double layered limitation on president's removal power was deemed unconstitutional. It came to this reasoning because a President cannot fulfill his or her duty if he or she runs into a situation where he or she cannot exercise oversight over an official. !!!

In Bowsher v. Synar, 478 U.S. 714 (1986), the Court ruled that Congress by itself could not remove any executive officer except by impeachment.

Power in Foreign Affairs

Some foreign affairs powers belong to the President, some to Congress, some to the President-and-Senate; some can be exercised by either the President or Congress, some require the joint authority of both. Irregular, uncertain division renders claims of usurpation more difficult to establish and the courts have not been available to adjudicate them. Professor Louis Henkin, in Foreign Affairs and the Constitution (1972)

This power is granted to the Federal Government in the Constitution and makes sense. It is essential for a country to have a single body representing it on a global scale. The President acts as the sole organ of the nation in its external relations, and its sole representative with foreign nations. Insisting that the President act as the face is intended to prevent embarrassment and present the country as united under a single voice on the global scale.

War

Congress has the power to Declare War while the President has the power to Conduct War.

The War Powers Resolution Act was brought in the shadow of the Vietnam war which aimed to curtail the power of the Executive to conduct military operations around the globe. It placed specific limits on the time and type of military "excursions" that can be conducted by the executive, but it has proven to be somewhat ineffective in preventing the executive from engaging in armed conflict with non-state actors. The War on Terror and War on Drugs are examples of this.

Treaty Power

The President negotiates treaties, then brings those negotiated treaties back to enact them depending on approval of 2/3rds of the Senate

The President may also enter into Executive Treaties with other countries with other countries without Senate advice.

Both these forms of treaties are considered the supreme law of the land and preempt any state laws. If there is a conflict between a self-executing treaty and a federal statute, whichever is more recent in time will preempt (Whitney).

United States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp. (1936) This case asked whether Congress was permitted to delegate to the President some “quasi-legislative” authority with respect to foreign affairs. The fact that Congress was recognized to have the authority to make broad delegations of power over foreign relations (apparently broader than with respect to domestic issues) does not mean that the President’s power to act unilaterally is unlimited. To the extent that Congress shares control over foreign relations, it need not delegate power to the President. Indeed, Congress may limit the President’s authority over matters that the Constitution assigns concurrently to Congress and the President.

Trump v. Hawaii (2018) (The President has the ability to exercise discretion in ensuring the safety of the Country, as long as their actions are rationally related to the goal of national security.)

Zivotofsky v. Kerry (2015) (The power to recognize foreign nations lies squarley within the power of the executive and Congress cannot direct the President to recognize a foreign nation.

Appointment and Removal Power

Article 2 section 2 states that the President shall nominate with the advice and consent of the Senate officers of the executive. Congress may vest appointment power in the president, courts, or heads of department.

Morrison v. Olsen

Alexa Morrison was appointed as an independent counsel to investigate an EPA official and his subordinates for their failure to comply with a subpoena to hand over documents to Congress.

the Court upheld a statute providing for the appointment of an independent counsel to investigate specified wrongdoing by high-level executive branch officials. Once appointed, the independent counsel was removable only by the Attorney General, and only for cause. This was one of the myriad constitutional objections levied at the statute. In an 8-1 decision, with Scalia offering a famous dissent. Scalia's opinion has been the one which court has trended towards in recent years. It was fully adopted in the Trump v. Slaughter case in 2026.

Instead of a categorical approach to determine if this is a valid limit, the Court takes a more functional approach. It asks if Congress may place limits on the removal of an executive officer because the function of the officer is "quasi-legislative" or "quasi-judicial". In Scalia's dissent, he takes a more categorical approach, which is a textualist interpretation of the constitution.

What makes an officer inferior?

In Edmond v. United States (1997), the court found that interior officer connotes a relationship with a higher-ranking officer below the president. Kennedy v. Braidwood (2025) reaffirmed this decision.

Congress cannot remove any officers by itself, except through impeachment.

Trump v. Slaughter (2026)

in Myers v. United States (1926), the court held that the Constitution grants to the President the general administrative control of those executing the laws, including the power of appointment and removal of executive officers. There are several departments in the executive branch which deviate from this model, this deviation was created by the Humphrey's Executor v. United States (1935) case (There are some presidentially appointed officials, he explained, who may perform “executive functions” but exercise “no part of the executive power.” And for those officials, “the decision in the Myers case cannot be accepted as controlling).

In this case, Trump fired a few FTC commissioners without any cited just cause. The SC then reviewed this decision to determine if that action was permitted by past case law, namely Morisson v. Olsen. The Court decided that "the FTC unquestionably exercises executive power, and must therefore be controlled by the Chief Executive, in whom such power is vested. It follows, then, that Slaughter served as the President’s subordinate at the FTC—and that the President was
entitled to cut her tenure short."

The dissent in this case is persuasive to me, as it reminds the reader of the need to allow certain government functions to "operate at a distance from partisan politics."

#Constitutional Law #Executive #Powers of Executive