Preclusion
Preclusion of Claims
Claim Preclusion is the legal doctrine that one is not able to assert a claim which one has previously litigated or had a full and fair opportunity to litigate.
Requirements for a Claim to be Precluded
Same Claim
Same Party
Same Transaction
Judgement on the Merits
Claim preclusion requires that the claim being precluded is one which the party had a full and fair opportunity to litigate in a previous action. This concept works of the principles of Efficiency and Consistency. The courts do not want to waste time on claims already litigated, or those which had a full and fair opportunity to be litigated. The court also wants to prevent the same or similar claims from reaching opposite results, which would compromise the consistency of judgements in the court system.
Rule 8© lists claim preclusion (which the Rule calls res judicata) as an affirmative defense: Failure to plead and prove an affirmative defense results in waiving it.
Same Parties
Mutuality must be present for claim preclusion to apply.
Same Claim
In most jurisdictions, the Transaction approach is used which asks if the claim arises out of the transaction which was the subject of previous litigation.
The claim must be one which is either the same as the one brought in the previous case, or it must be one which was compulsory (based on whether the state applies the "Same Transaction" test or the "Same Evidence" test.)
Same Transaction Test (Majority)
This test asks whether the subsequent claim being brought is arose out of the same transaction as the previous claim. If it did, then the party had a full and fair opportunity to bring the claim in the previous action and has waived it by failing to bring it at that time.
The transactional approach is what Illinois courts now follow. The same evidence test has been done away with in Illinois.
Before a claim can be precluded from being raised, it must have been a claim at the time of the first suit.
A similar principle prevents claim preclusion from applying if the court rendering the first judgment lacked jurisdiction over the allegedly precluded claim.
Nor does the transactional definition extend to claims arising from the same episode but belonging to different parties.
Same Evidence Test (Minority)
This test asks whether the subsequent claim being brought requires the same evidence to litigate as the previous claim. If it does, then that claim will be precluded.
Jones v. City of Alton (My Hometown): One suit precludes a second where the parties and the cause of action are identical. Causes of action are identical where the evidence necessary to sustain a second verdict would sustain the first
Same Party
As briefly discussed above, claim preclusion does not apply to the same claim brought by a different party. This is because it is an essential principle of American Jurisprudence that a party is not subject to the authority of a decision in which he or she was not a party.
Final Judgement
The court must have issued a decision which is final, whether that be a classic verdict (from the bench or a jury) or a dismissal (voluntary or involuntary).
Courts and treaties say that claim preclusion requires a prior final judgement. Courts do not literally interpret the final judgement requirement.
Some administrative determinations may be entitled to claim-preclusion effect if the procedure employed contains sufficient due process protections.
On the Merits
The judgement must be one which is valid. This means, in part, that it needs to be made by a court with jurisdiction
An “adjudication upon the merits” is the opposite of a “dismissal without prejudice"
Semtek Intl. Inc. v. Lockheed Martin Corp. (The court found that a dismissal based on a lapse in the Statute of Limitations does not preclude a claim from being brought in a separate forum with valid jurisdiction which has a longer SOL period. State law governs preclusion in diversity actions, which is what the case was here.)
- An important factor to remember is that a judgement by a court without valid jurisdiction does not offer any preclusive effect.
Preclusion of Issues
This principle bars certain issues from relitigation if those issues had been actually litigated and determined. This applies to subsequent claims involving the same transaction if they involve the same party or if they involve different parties. If different parties are involved, it is up to the judge to determine if issue preclusion is acceptable.
Defensive Issue Preclusion
A defendant seeks to preclude an issue that a plaintiff had previously litigated and lost against another defendant. Blonder-Tongue case.
It serves as incentive for the plaintiff to join all possible parties in his or her initial claim.
Offensive Issue Preclusion
a plaintiff seeks to estop a defendant from relitigating the issues which the defendant previously litigated and lost against another plaintiff.Illinois Gulf RR case.
This provides incentive for a defendant to settle a case if an issue is likely to be ruled adversely to his or her interests.
Mutuality and Issue Preclusion
Mutuality used to be required in Issue Preclusion. This was done away with in the Illinois Gulf RR case. In its place, the court is instructed to generally allow offensive issue preclusion, but to act within its discretion in denying offensive issue preclusion if the following elements are present;
The plaintiff could have easily joined the earlier plaintiff in his or her initial action.
Issue preclusion would be unfair to the defendant because;
The defendant had little incentive to defend vigorously if the initial claim was nominal
If there are inconsistencies in ruling on the issue in past cases.
If the second action affords the defendant procedural opportunities not present in past action.
If it is otherwise unfair to the defendant.
A Brief Word on the Full Faith and Credit Clause
Courts in one jurisdiction must give full faith and credit to the decisions made in its sister jurisdictions. It is not up to one jurisdiction to examine the merits of a final judgement in a sister jurisdiction.
V.L. v. E.L. (Supreme Court reversed the decision of the Alabama supreme court because it reversed the decision of a Georgia court because it found that the Georgia court did not adhere to Georgia State Law. This was not permitted because a court is not allowed to examine the merits of a final judgement on the merits in a sister jurisdiction).