Separation of Powers and Federalism
The last three articles provide the components of our government, Article IV gives the instructions as to how they work together, alongside each other and among the several states.
It is thought that the founders intended that the branches act together with checks and balances on each other. This is to prevent one branch from a degree of power which would give rise to tyranny, a big concern at the time (and today!).
An example of this is the Nondelegation clause of Article I, which states that Congress may not delegate its powers to another branch to encourage (Accountability and Predictability).
The Administrative State raises concerns about the maintenance of the Separation of Powers, which will be touched on more in a separate post.
Clauses of Article IV
Article IV contains the Supremacy Clause, which states that the constitution and all valid laws passed by Congress preempt the laws of the states. It also provides the Full Faith and Credit clause, which requires jurisdictions to respect the judgements of sister jurisdictions. It also allows for adequate and independent laws created by the state governments.
The Privileges and Immunities Clause is also included in this and protects fundamental rights afforded to residents of the US.
Finally, the article states that it will protect all states from invasion. It is the job of the President to ensure that all of these requirements are adhered to. More about this in a separate post.
Supremacy
A reason why the states are so concerned about tyranny, and why the separation of power is important, is because Article IV states that federal law is the Supreme Law of the Land. This power is so great, that if used irresponsibly could lead to grave injury to the American People.
On the Contrary, it can be used to ensure that the states do not enact laws which run contrary to the laws and principles of the Constitution. Martin v. Hunter's Lessee establishes that federal law is the supreme law of the land.
Martin v. Hunter's Lessee
The Supremacy clause states that the Constitution is the supreme law of the land. Any act of Congress which validly derives its power from the constitution is also considered the supreme law of the land. Because of this, Federal law, if valid, will preempt state law which conflicts with it (more on this in the 'Preemption' blog post).
Martin v. Hunter's Lessee established that Congress had the power to create mechanisms for vertical judicial review, allowing the Supreme Court to review the decisions of state courts to determine if they adhere to the constitution and the valid laws of Congress.
Who is bound to the Supreme Court's Decisions?
Cooper v. Aaron stated that the following parties are bound;
Parties to a Supreme Court Case are bound to the decision.
State officials are bound to the Supreme Court's decisions, despite not being a party to it.
State Courts are bound by Supreme Court Decisions
(This case came up after the governor of Arkansas refused to adhere to the decision of Brown v. Board of Education by preventing the integration of schools.)
Full Faith and Credit
Full Faith and Credit shall be given in each State to the public Acts, Records, and judicial Proceedings of every other State. And the Congress may by general Laws prescribe the Manner in which such Acts, Records and Proceedings shall be proved, and the Effect thereof.
This comes up all the time when a claim being brought in one state is dismissed and then brought in another, or when the decision of a court in one state influences the decision of a pending lawsuit in another state.
Other Rights of the States
States are afforded the right to have power over things not listed in the constitution or things that were expressly granted to them. The right to administer elections is granted to the states independent of the federal government. Police Powers are left to the states,, alongside public education, family law, local government creation, licensing, and intrastate commerce.
The Right to More Rights: Independent and Adequate
States have the right to provide more or expanded rights to its citizens. The federal courts will not review the constitutionality of a decision of a lower court if it is based solely on a state law and that law is adequately meets the minimum requirements prescribed by the Constitution.
Michigan v. Long
The SC will not review a state court decision that rests on adequate and independent state grounds. To determine whether to review a state court decision, the court examines the following factors;
Adequacy of the state law basis for the decision
Its independence from Federal Law
Eleventh Amendment: "You Can't Sue Me!"
To determine if a suit against a state is valid, ask whether the plaintiff is a party to whom the Amendment applies and whether the state is being sued. You must also ask whether the suit is a controversy to which the State consented to be sued over.
The Judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States by Citizens of another State, or by Citizens or Subjects of any Foreign State.
The United States may sue a state, even if the purpose of the suit is to protect private individuals
The Eleventh Amendment is designed to prevent federal courts from issuing judgments that must be paid out of the state treasury.
Chisholm v. Georgia
Chisholm v. Georgia brought the issue that led to the Eleventh Amendment. Asked to decide a suit brought against the State of Georgia alleging that it owed a private individual money.
Alden v. Maine
The State of Maine has not consented to suit for actions related to overtime pay and liquidated damages under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) of 1938. Sovereign Immunity protects the state from suits it has not consented to.
The issue is whether a group of state employees (Probation Officers) had the right to sue their state (ME) in federal court pursuant to violations of the FLSA
Eleventh Amendment Immunity refers to the states' immunity from suit (in federal courts) as a fundamental character of their sovereignty.
In Hans v. Louisiana, the Court held that sovereign immunity barred a citizen from suing his own State under the federal-question head of jurisdiction. The Court was unmoved by the petitioner's argument that the Eleventh Amendment, by its terms, applied only to suits brought by citizens of other States.
The structure of the Constitution requires that Congress respect States' decision to spend their money. Requiring the states to pay out of their treasury upsets the relationship between the federal government and the States.
Seminole Tribe and College Savings Bank came at last to the conclusion that neither the Supremacy Clause nor the enumerated powers of Congress confer authority to abrogate the States' immunity from suit in federal court
Sovereign immunity bars suits against states only in the absence of consent.
The immunity does not extend to suits prosecuted against a municipal corporation or other governmental entity
There is no evidence that the State has manipulated its immunity in a systematic fashion to discriminate against federal causes of action. To the extent Maine has chosen to consent to certain classes of suits while maintaining its immunity from others,
Maine has immunity from the Plaintiffs' suit.
See Enumerated Powers Post for Information on the Dormant Commerce Clause
!!! INSERT IMAGE