Shareholder Proposals
Remember: Shareholders do not have any management rights. They only have Economic and Voting rights associated with their ownership in a company. A successful shareholder proposal then is implemented as a wider policy of the company. It must be big picture. The limits on what can be proposed are used to ensure that shareholders do not have managerial power on the business of the corporation.
What is it?
A provision that allows qualifying shareholders to put a proposal before their fellow shareholders for a vote by having the proposal placed on the Corporation's proxy statement, AND having the Corporation bear the expenses.
- Procedural Requirements
Shareholder must own stock a) $2k/3yrs b) $15k/2yrs or c) $25k/1yr
- Substantive Requirements
Proper subject under state law
!!!
cannot discuss personal grievances
must relate to over 5% of earnings or otherwise significantly relate
Not directly conflict with company's own proposal at same meeting
Cannot address management functions, but can word it as a "recommendation"
- Exclusions
Three Exclusions
The Company has already substantially implemented the proposal
The proposal substantially duplicates another proposal by another proponent that is set for the same meeting
Is the same proposal that failed within the last 5 years
SEC Rule 14a-8 is the rule associated with shareholder proposals.
Significantly Relate to Operations Requirement
Ordinary Course of Business Requirement
Election Matter Exclusion
Shareholder Inspections