Shareholder Voting Control
Shareholder Voting Control refers to the ways shareholders can allocate their voting power. This can be done though structure, described in the articles of incorporation, or through agreements in order to exercise control. It is all about how one can maximize one's vote to push the corporation in a desired direction.
Issues of Shareholder Voting Control
Control refers to the ability to control access to the profits generated by the corporation. Control of the board is ability to control money to the shareholders.
The way control is exercised differs between close corporations and public corporations. In close corporations, employees are often the ones with votes. This means that they may prefer to get their money through salaries rather than dividends (remember that dividends are double taxed). Shareholder employees want control over who is on the board.
In public corporations, the shareholder is often an individual not concerned with the internal consequences of actions but rather the profits that can be generated by a decision to maximize dividends.
Under ordinary voting rules, minority shareholders do not have the ability to effectively influence who is on the board. Fiduciary duties are present to protect minority shareholders, but as discussed there are many ways to skirt around some fiduciary duties. Devices for Voting Control is the other system designed to give minority shareholders a say in what the decisions of the Corporation.
Espinoza v. Facebook (Board votes to give itself a raise and the question is whether Zuckerberg could ratify the decision to cleanse it, because the board has a conflict of interest in voting on it. Court found that Zuckerberg should have ratified it through the proper channels). A stockholder's ratification must comply with the formalities required by state law. The standard in this is entire fairness.
Shareholders can vote in their own self-interest and act selfishly, but board members may not act in their own self-interest; they must act in the best interest of all shareholders (duty of loyalty). Thus, the bOard must be free to make decisions
Shareholders can agree to exercise control to determine who will be on the board, but not determine how those board members will vote in the future.
Class of Stock as a Voting Control Device
Stocks are bundles of rights containing Economic Rights and Voting Rights. Shareholder voting controls in the form of separate classes of stock are allowed when set up correctly and all shareholders have notice.
Common Stock
Preferred Stock
Non-Voting Shares
Stroh v. Blackhawk Holding, Inc. (1971) (Court found that the creation of stock with only voting rights was permitted as voting rights is a proprietary right).
Other Devices for Shareholder Voting Control
Voting Trusts: One concedes control to a trustee who is responsible for voting all of one's shares. Most states limits this to a ten year period.
Shareholder Agreements: Broad category of agreements among shareholders that deal with a variety of matters relating to the corporation. Vote Pooling Agreements are an example of this.
Irrevocable Proxies: When it comes to proxies, the general rule is that proxies are revocable. This device is used to give one entity control; one or more shareholders hand over their voters to a third party to increase that person's control. To make it irrevocable, there must be another coupled interest in the corporation.
Vote Pooling Agreement: When two or more shareholders declare that they are going to vote in a certain way, based on some criteria. It is very flexible but may lead to deadlock and enforceability issues.
Ringling Bros.-Barnum & Bailey Case (Court held the the vote pooling agreement was valid and that there was a breach, and that the vote must be redone.)
Cumulative Voting: Each shareholder gets number of votes equal to number of board vacancies multiplied by number off share owned.
Straight Voting: Whoever has the majority will win every vote.
Close v. Public Corporations
Public Corporation: Usually own small percentage of shares as part of diversified portfolio. Interested in share price. If unhappy, the wall street rule is used (sell!)
Close Corporation: Undiversified, interested in company's performance and dividends, not share price. Minority shareholders may have little influence on Board of Directors Management