Specific Jurisdiction
A court’s exercise of specific jurisdiction may be constitutional when the defendant has contacts with the forum that give rise to, or are related to, the plaintiff’s cause of action. It is allowed only if it does not offend traditional notions of Fair Play and Substantive Justice
The factors for determining Specific Jurisdiction are;
Purposeful Availment (World-Wide Volkswagon, J. McIntyre, Ltd. v. Nicastro)
Relatedness (Ford Motor Co.)
Reasonableness (Daimler AG)
Purposeful Availment
Requires that the Defendant's contacts within the Forum were such that they could reasonably anticipate being brought into court in that Forum. Foreseeability alone is not the benchmark.
Purposeful availment is not a foreseeability analysis, but rather an examination of whether or not the Party Targeted the forum. Targeting refers to gearing activity towards the forum for some type of benefit, often economic.
J. McIntyre Machinery, L. v. Nicastro (Found that one is not subject to Specific Jurisdiction if one did not target the forum state to derive a benefit from activities within that forum state.)
Relatedness
The case must “arise out of or relate to the defendant’s contacts with the forum."
Ford Motor Corp. v. Montana (Court found that Ford purposefully availed itself of the market in Montana through advertisement and service shops in the state despite not having a dealership within the state. This is because one within the state can be influenced to purchase a ford due to the advertisement and services provided in the state by Ford.)
Reasonableness
The exercise of Specific Jurisdiction must comport with notions of Fair Play and Substantive Justice.
The Factors establishing Reasonableness, which are to be weighed, are as follows:
“the burden on the defendant” ;
“the forum State’s interest in adjudicating the dispute” ;
“the plaintiff’s interest in obtaining convenient and effective relief” ;
“the interstate judicial system’s interest in obtaining the most efficient resolution of controversies” ;
and the “shared interest of the several States in furthering fundamental substantive social policies.”
Daimler AG v. Bauman (2006) (Court found that it would be unreasonable to subject Daimler AG to the jurisdiction of California in relation to alleged crimes committed in Argentina during the Dirty War.)
Applying the Elements of Specific Jurisdiction: World-Wide Volkswagon Corp. v. Woodson
In this case, a family purchased a vehicle in New York and used it to move to Arizona. While on the way there, they got into an accident due to vehicle malfunction in Oklahoma. They attempted to bring suit against the dealership in an Oklahoma court. The court denied Specific Jurisdiction over the dealership in Oklahoma for the following reasons;
The Dealership did not operate in Oklahoma in any capacity, failing to meet the minimum contacts requirement with the state.
The selling of the car in New York did not arise out of the contacts the dealership had with Oklahoma.
It would be unreasonable to subject the dealership, with no contacts to a forum, to the jurisdiction of the forum.
Specificity of Injury Requirement: Bristol-Myers Squibb v. Superior Court
A class action cannot bring in individuals with not connection to the forum state on the basis that they experienced the same injury as those domiciled within the forum state. This means that those within a class action must either bring the case in a forum with General Jurisidition over the Defendant, or each defendant brings the action in the forums with specific jurisidiction connected to their independent injury.
Specific Jurisdiction and the Internet: Zippo Mfg. Co. v. Zippo Dot Com.
Looks at two different types of Web Pages;
Websites where the users simply post things without sharing their location or personal information.
- This type does not open the door to Specific Jurisdiction.
Websites where users must submit personal information, like name and address, in order to use the services of the site.
- This type opens the door to Specific Jurisdiction.