Earnest Work

The Erie Doctrine

The Erie case overruled the precedent on Swift v. Taylor, which supported a view that "general law" preceded state law when a case is being heard in federal court on the basis of Diversity Jurisdiction.

In the opinion written by J. Brandeis, the court found that federal judges should use state law, which includes statutes and state common law, when it concerns laws which are substantive to the decision of the case, meaning laws which could potentially determine the outcome.

Erie holds only that “general” federal common law may not displace that of the states in areas in which the Constitution rests lawmaking power in the states. But—confined to its proper sphere—federal common law continues to flourish: Think of the hundreds of federal causes of action, in which courts must supplement general statutory or constitutional principles with judge-made common law.

Swift v. Tyson ()

Erie Railroad v. Tompkins (1938) (The case which established the Erie Doctrine. It found that in Diversity Jurisdiction, the court should adhere to the laws and court precedent in the state in which the claim arises when deciding a case.)

Guaranty Trust Co. v. York (1945) (The Outcome-Determinative Test is used to determine what is considered manner and means of enforcement. It asks whether the state rule is one which would be determinative of the outcome, if not then federal courts need not follow it. This allowed federal courts to utilize rules of Federal Procedure rather than State Procedural rules)

Byrd v. Blue Ridge Rural Electric Cooperative (1958):

The Federal system is viewed as a different process than that of the state court, and that separate process is valid and not in violation of the Erie Doctrine. Whether or not the federal court may proceed depends on a multi-factor analysis.

  1. Is the rule in question bound up in the substantive rights of the parties? If Yes, apply State Law.
  2. Does the difference in rule lead to a strong likelihood of differing outcomes?
  3. Does the federal government have affirmative countervailing considerations?

Uniformity does not require strict adherence to state law. Can the two bodies of law exist with the goals of consistency and respect to countervailing considerations? The Seventh Amendment is the countervailing interest in the above case.

The Modern Erie Doctrine

The Hanna case reframed the issue in Erie from one involving a constitutional question to a statutory one. It placed 28 USC s 2072 and the Rules of Decision at the front of the analysis of cases involving the Erie Doctrine.

Hanna v. Plumer (1965)

If the Federal Procedural Rule controls if it is deemed valid, that is it does not abridge, enlarge, or modify the substantive rights provided in state law. If there is a federal rule of civil procedure that is on point, it controls.

Byrd and Hanna reach similar results: Both hold that the federal court need not behave as a state court would if it were hearing the case. Moreover, both created multi-tiered “tests” for determining whether federal or state practice should prevail.

Federal Preemption

For federal law to preempt, the federal law must be constitutional and otherwise valid. To preempt, according to standard doctrine, a federal law must in some sense be intended to displace state law.

How should a federal court decide which state’s law to apply, and how should it resolve questions about the interpretation of state law?

Each state has a body of law called its choice of law rules, which specify the circumstances in which courts of that state should follow laws of other jurisdictions, such as those of other states, federal law, or foreign law.

Klaxon Co. v. Stentor Elec. Mfg. Co., 313 U.S. 487 (1941), in which the Supreme Court applied Erie principles to conflicts rules: Under Erie, a federal court sitting in diversity (or exercising supplemental jurisdiction) Must apply the conflicts principles of the forum state

Van Dusen v. Barrack, 376 U.S. 612 (1964) (holding that even when a case is transferred to a federal court in another state it “takes with it” the substantive law and choice of law rules of the state where it was originally filed)

Erie Guess

Federal courts must do their best to determine how a state court would have ruled in the absence of recent and useful precedent on an issue. If it is clear how a state court would interpret the law , then the federal court should defer to that interpretation. The same rule applies to federal appellate courts.

Holdings based on such predictions of state court views (sometimes referred to as “Erie guesses”) are awkward, especially if the predictions later turn out to be wrong.

DeWeerth v. Baldinger, 38 F.3d 1266 (2d Cir.), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 1001 (1994).

In 1987, plaintiff invoked diversity jurisdiction to sue a New York art dealer to recover a Monet painting stolen from his family during World War II. The federal court ruled that DeWeerth had failed to satisfy what it understood to be the showing of reasonable diligence in locating stolen property required by state law. Four years later the New York courts in a similar case held that a showing of reasonable diligence was not required under the relevant statute.

Mckesson v. Doe (2020)

#Civil Procedure #Erie Doctrine