Subject Matter Jurisdiction
Subject Matter Jurisdiction is the second pillar of jurisdiction which must be met for a court to have valid authority over a matter. Courts of General Subject Matter Jurisdiction may hear a wide variety of controversies not reserved for specialized courts.
For a Federal Court to have Subject Matter Jurisdiction over a controversy, the controversy must either present a =Federal Question= or meet the requirements for Diversity Jurisdiction set out in 28 USC 1331 and 1332.
Federal Question
To determine if a Federal Question is raised, the Creation Test is used. It asks if the claim;
Necessarily raises a federal issue (Relates to a Federal Statute or the Constitution)
The issue is Actually disputed and substantial.
The Federal Forum can entertain the claim without disturbing any congressionally approved balance of federal and state judicial responsibilities.
Louisville Nashville RR (Court found that a plaintiff must show that a claim arises through a well plead complaint and cannot establish Federal Jurisdiction by anticipating a Federal Question)
Diversity Jurisdiction
Read the 1331 and 1332 statutes. It's really the only way to understand the law. Read it more than once!
Essentially, Diversity jurisdiction is allowed when the parties on either side of the "v" are from different states (US States and Foreign States). In addition to this requirement, the damages must exceed $75,000.
The question of Domicile is essential to establishing Diversity Jurisdiction. Domicile refers to the place one is living and plans to stay indefinitely. This is a fact specific question, and the court may look at where the party keeps his or her belongings, where the family resides, where they have established his or her professional career.