Constitutional Law: Structure and Powers
Structure of Government
Branches of Government
Article I: Legislative
Article I of the US Constitution dictated the role and power of the legislative branch. The article provided a list of enumerated powers on which Congress can act. It also provided some limits the legislative branch in how it may conduct itself.
Article II: Executive
Article III: Judiciary
Separation of Powers
Article IV
Internal Limitations
External Limitations
Legislative and Executive Checks and Balances
Legislative Checks on Executive
Executive Checks on Judiciary
Legislative and Judiciary Checks and Balances
Legislative Checks on Judiciary
Judiciary Checks on Legislative
Judiciary and Executive Checks and Balances
Executive Checks on Judiciary
Judiciary Checks on Executive
Checks and Balances
Federalism
Article IV
McCulloch v. Maryland
Martin v. Hunter's Lessee
State's Rights
Independent and Adequate
Full Faith and Credit
Eleventh Amendment
Powers
Powers of Legislative Branch
Refer to the Post on the Enumerated Powers
The Enumerated Powers contain an exhaustive list of powers granted to Congress. To exercise these powers, Congress may pass legislation that is necessary and proper to do so.
Necessary and Proper Clause
Commerce Power
Article I, section 8, clause 3 confers upon Congress the power to regulate three different types of commerce;
Commerce with Foreign Nations (Foreign Commerce)
Commerce among the states (Interstate Commerce)
Commerce with Native American Tribes
Lopez Rule
The Lopez rule is as follows;
Congress may regulate the use of the channels of interstate commerce (Heart of Atlanta Motel);
Congress is empowered to regulate and protect the instrumentalities of interstate commerce, or persons or things in Interstate commerce
Commerce, even though the threat may come only from intrastate activities (Wickard);
Congress's commerce authority includes the power to regulate those activities having a substantial relation to interstate commerce (Jones & Laughlin Steel). Determining if there is a substantial affect on Interstate commerce requires an analysis using these four factors;
Is the activity economic in nature?
Whether the legislation contains a jurisdictional element limiting its reach to activity that affects interstate commerce. (Is there something in the legislation that says "...affects commerce"?)
Whether Congress made findings demonstrating the effect of the regulated activity on interstate commerce.
Whether the effect on interstate commerce is substantial or attenuated.
Dormant Commerce Clause
Two requirements for Dormant Commerce Clause Claim;
State attempts to regulate interstate or foreign commerce and
Congress has not acted to regulate that commerce
The burden falls on the challenger to prove the burden imposed on interstate commerce is clearly excessive in relation to the putative local benefits.
Modern Interpretation of the Dormant Commerce Clause
If a state regulation openly discriminates against interstate commerce, the regulation is presumed to be invalid. The regulation is valid only if the state can prove that it furthers a legitimate state interest that cannot be accomplished by any less discriminatory means.
- “Does this state regulation so interfere with the national interest in maintaining a free flow of interstate commerce that the local benefits of the regulation are comparatively slight?”
If a state regulation is nondiscriminatory and has only incidental effects on interstate commerce, it is presumed valid.
The regulation is void only if the challenger can prove that the burden imposed on interstate commerce is clearly excessive in relation to the putative local benefits of the regulation.
If a regulation is deemed valid, the loser has recourse with Congress, and can attempt to get congress to pass legislation that preempts the court's judgement.
Limitations on Commerce Power
Congress could not use the commerce power to impinge upon a state’s policy choices in matters that are traditionally regarded as governmental (Police, Sanitation, Public Health, etc...)
For a limitation on Commerce Power to be imposed, the following elements must be met:
A showing that the challenged statute regulates the "States as States"
The federal regulation must address matters that are indisputably "attributes of state sovereignty"
It must be apparent that the State's compliance with the federal law would directly impair their ability "to structure integral operations in areas of traditional government functions."
Anticommandeering Doctrine
Presumption against congressional interference with state decisions that are “fundamental [for] a sovereign,” and stating that only a clear and unequivocal statement of congressional intent to invade the domain of state sovereignty could suffice to establish that the statute had such an effect.
The anticommandeering doctrine does not apply when Congress evenhandedly regulates an activity in which both States and private actors engage.
Taxing Power
Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes...to provide for the common defense and general welfare of the United States.
As long as something raises revenue, it is within Congress' taxing power
The court looks at 3 things to determine if a tax is valid;
Proportionality (Is the tax proportional to the action)
Scienter (Is there an element of intent present in the statute?)
Enforcement (Who is enforcing the tax? The IRS or some other body which often enforces penalties?)
Limits on Taxing Power
Congress may not tax exports
Congress may not discriminate among or against states in exercising its taxing power.
A tax cannot impair the soveriegn state functions through taxing.
Revenue raised from any direct taxes must be proportional to the state's population
Congress cannot impose a tax that would violate some other constitutional provision.
A consistent problem for the court is determining what is a tax to raise revenue vs what is a tax to penalize?
Spending Power
Congress may spend for anything it reasonably thinks will further the “general welfare” of the nation; it is not limited to spending in aid of its specific regulatory objectives. But this power is not unlimited.
- If spending is entirely regulatory and Congress has no source of regulatory authority, the spending initiative is invalid as an improper and pretextual means to attain an ultra vires end.
Treaty Powers
Art. II s. 2 states that the president has the power to negotiate treaties, and may implement treaties if 2/3rds of the Senate Agrees.
Treaties made under the authority of the United States [are] declared the supreme law of the land.
What an act of Congress could not do unaided, in derogation of the powers reserved to the States, a treaty cannot do.
Limits on the Treaty Power
Whatever the subject of the treaty is, it must also be the subject of negotiation with a foreign country.
Matters of the sharpest exigency for the national well being.
No agreement with a foreign power is free from the restraints of the Constitution.
War Powers
Congress has the ability to declare war on foreign nations, but the President has the power to conduct war.
Immunities and Privileges
Powers of Executive
Enumerated Powers
Take Care Clause
Appointment and Removal Powers
War Powers
Immunities and Privileges
Powers of Judiciary
Original and Appellate Jurisdiction
Original Jurisdiction
Appellate Jurisdiction
Judicial Review
Marbury v. Madison
Methods of Judicial Review