Civil Procedure II: Jurisdictions and Joinder
Due Process
"No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws." - Fourteenth Amendment
Requirements of Due Process
Adequate Notice
Sufficient Jurisdiction
Opportunity to be Heard
Neutral Decision Maker
Procedural Due Process ensures that the court operates under principles of Fundamental Fairness.It works to make our system predictable, which fosters trust in the system.
Due Process Analysis
Notice
Constitutional Requirements of Notice
Reasonably Calculated to provide notice.
Affords opposition reasonable time to formulate response.
Trial Rule 4: Federal Service Requirements
State Rules of Notice
Blood-Dzairaku
Personal Jurisdiction
A court must have bother personal and subject matter jurisdiction over parties in a lawsuit. Personal Jurisdiction can be established through a finding of General Jurisdiction or Specific Jurisdiction.
See the post on the Evolution of Personal Jurisdiction in American jurisprudence
General
Refer to the Post on General Jurisdiction
General Jurisdiction looks at where a party is
Domiciled or
Physically present or
Incorporated or
Operating its Principal Place of Business
Domicile
Where a party is physically present and where they inteded to remain indefinitely at the time the complaint was filed.
Physical presence can be established by the party owning a house within the jurisdiction, operating a business within the jurisdiction, or otherwise living within a jurisdiction.
The intent to remain indefinitely requires that the party intends to stay at the location within the jurisdiction. (This finding can be supported by facts relating to where the party works, where his or her family is located, where his or her belongings are located, etc...)
Tag Jurisdiction
Burnham v. Superior Court outtake
This avenue of establishing general jurisdiction is considered foundational to American jurisprudence and only requires that the party be located within the jurisdiction when served the complaint
Place of Incorporation
The state in which a corporation files its articles of incorporation has general jurisdicition over the corporation.
This leads Delaware to be a common place of incorporation because it is considered corporation friendly, making potential plaintiffs wary of filing complaints againss the corporation in the state.
Principal Place of Business
Contacts with a state that are such to render the corporation at home in that state.
LLC Rule
The forum in which members of an LLC reside has general jurisdiction over cases related to the LLC.
The fourm in which the nerve center of the LLC is located has general jurisdiction over cases realted to the LLC.
Specific
Refer to Post about Specific Jurisdiction
Allowed only if the exercise of jurisdiction does not offend traditional notions of Fair Play and Substantive Justice
The factors for determining Specific Jurisdiction are;
Purposeful Availment (World-Wide Volkswagon, J. McIntyre, Ltd. v. Nicastro)
Relatedness (Ford Motor Co.)
Reasonableness (Daimler AG)
Consent
Contract
One may assent to having cases relating to a contract heard in a specific jurisdiction.
Long Arm Statute
States may have statutes which require that if an individual or corporation is to take part in one of the activities enumerated in a statute, that individual or corporation assents to the state having jurisdiction over the party in all matters related to the activity.
Minimum Contacts
Jurisdiction depends on the extent of the defendant’s contacts in the state in relation to the claim asserted. This is a sliding scale that requires a balancing test to determine whether a Forum could hear a case.
Refer to the Post on International Shoe
Intl. Shoe Analysis
Subject Matter Jurisdiction
Refer to the Post on Subject Matter Jurisdiction
Diversity Jurisdiction
Read the 1331 and 1332 statutes.
Complete Diversity plus amount in Damages exceeds $75K
Complete Diversity requires that the parties on both sides of the v. are not from the same state.
Exceeds $75k requires that the amount in damages is reasonably expected to exceed $75k.
Federal Question
To determine if a Federal Question is raised, the Creation Test is used. It asks if the claim;
Necessarily raises a federal issue (Relates to a Federal Statute or the Constitution)
The issue is Actually disputed and substantial.
The Federal Forum can entertain the claim without disturbing any congressionally approved balance of federal and state judicial responsibilities.
Supplemental Jurisdiction
Refer to the Post on Supplemental Jurisdiction
The statute which rules whether Supplemental Jurisdiction applies is 28 USC s. 1367
Supplemental Jurisdiction Requirements
If the Federal Claim arises from a Federal Question
- The federal court will have supplemental jurisdiction over all claims which form part of the same case or controversy as the federal claim
If the Federal Claim arises from a Diversity Claim
- The federal court will have supplemental jurisdiction over all claims which are part of the same case or controversy which contains a common nucleus of operative fact.
The court may decline to exercise Supplemental Jurisdiction if
The state-claim raises a novel or complex issue of State law;
The state-claim substantially predominates over the claim or claims over which the district court has original jurisdiction;
The district court has dismissed all claims over which it has original jurisdiction; or
In exceptional circumstances, there are other compelling reasons for declining jurisdiction.
Concurrent Jurisdiction
Removal and Remand
Venue
28 USC s. 1391
A civil action may be brought in;
A judicial district in which any defendant resides, if all defendants are residents of the State in which the district is located
A judicial district in which a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or
If there is no district in which an action may otherwise be brought as provided in this section, any judicial district in which any defendant is subject to the court's personal jurisdiction with respect to such action.
Reynor v. Piper
Application of Law: Erie Doctrine
Refer to Post on the Erie Doctrine
Erie Railroad v. Tompkins (1938), the case which established the Erie Doctrine. It found that in Diversity Jurisdiction, the court should adhere to the laws and court precedent in the state in which the claim arises when deciding a case.
Erie holds only that “general” federal common law may not displace that of the states in areas in which the Constitution rests lawmaking power in the states. But—confined to its proper sphere—federal common law continues to flourish: Think of the hundreds of federal causes of action, in which courts must supplement general statutory or constitutional principles with judge-made common law.
Goal of Erie Doctrine
Discouragement of forum-shopping and avoidance of inequitable administration of the laws.
Outcome-Determinative Test
Developed in the Guaranty Trust Co. v. York (1938) case, it is used to determine what is considered "manner and means of enforcement". It asks whether the state rule is one which would be determinative of the outcome, if not then federal courts need not follow it.
The Hanna case reframed the issue in Erie from one involving a constitutional question to a statutory one. It placed 28 USC s 2072 and the Rules of Decision at the front of the analysis of cases involving the Erie Doctrine.
The “outcome-determination” test cannot be read without reference to the twin aims of the Erie rule: discouragement of forum-shopping and avoidance of inequitable administration of the laws.
Federal Preemption
For federal law to preempt, the federal law must be constitutional and otherwise valid. To preempt, according to standard doctrine, a federal law must in some sense be intended to displace state law.
Erie Guess
Federal courts must do their best to determine how a state court would have ruled in the absence of recent and useful precedent on an issue. If it is clear how a state court would interpret the law , then the federal court should defer to that interpretation. The same rule applies to federal appellate courts.
Preclusion
Fair and Full Opportunity to be heard
Issue Preclusion
This principle bars certain issues from relitigation if those issues had been actually litigated and determined. This applies to subsequent claims involving the same transaction if they involve the same party or if they involve different parties. If different parties are involved, it is up to the judge to determine if issue preclusion is acceptable.
It is made up of two types of Issue Preclusion; Defensive an Offensive.
Defensive Issue Preclusion
A defendant seeks to preclude an issue that a plaintiff had previously litigated and lost against another defendant. Blonder-Tongue case. It serves as incentive for the plaintiff to join all possible parties in his or her initial claim.
Offensive Issue Preclusion
a plaintiff seeks to estop a defendant from relitigating the issues which the defendant previously litigated and lost against another plaintiff.Illinois Gulf RR case. This provides incentive for a defendant to settle a case if an issue is likely to be ruled adversely to his or her interests.
Mutuality
The court is instructed to use discretion in allowing offensive issue preclusion by analyzing the following factors.
The plaintiff could have easily joined the earlier plaintiff in his or her initial action.
Issue preclusion would be unfair to the defendant because;
The defendant had little incentive to defend vigorously if the initial claim was nominal
If there are inconsistencies in ruling on the issue in past cases.
If the second action affords the defendant procedural opportunities not present in past action.
If it is otherwise unfair to the defendant.
Claim Preclusion
Requirements for a Claim to be Precluded
Same Claim
- Claim must be one that party either brought or had a full and fair opportunity to bring in the previous litigation
Same Party
- Mutuality must be present
Same Transaction
Same Transaction Test
- Claim arises out of same occurrence or transaction which was subject of previous litigation
Same Evidence Test
- The subsequent claim requires the same evidence to litigate as the previous case
Judgement on the Merits
- The court offers a final judgement which is made by a court with valid jurisdiction and with prejudice
Joinder
“Under the Rules, the impulse is toward entertaining the broadest possible scope of action consistent with fairness to the parties; joinder of claims, parties and remedies is strongly encouraged.” United Mine Workers of America v. Gibbs, 383 U.S. 715 (1966).
Joinder of Claims
Refer to the Post on Joinder of Claims
R. 18 A plaintiff may include as many independent or alternative claims against an opposing party (Unrestricted Joinder). These claims do not need to arise out of the same transaction or occurrence.
If in federal court, each claim must meet Subject Matter or Supplemental Jurisdiction (refer to 28 USC s. 1367) requirements. While R. 18 permits the addition of claims arising out of separate transactions, it does not require it.
Compulsory Joinder of Claims
R. 13 allows for and sometimes requires that defendants assert claims against a plaintiff which arise out of the transaction which caused the suit. The rule has two kinds of joinder, permissive and compulsory.
Counterclaims and Cross Claims must arise out of the same transaction as the anchor claim.
- Compulsory counterclaims fall under the supplemental jurisdiction of federal courts because one is forced to bring them or waive recovery on the issue.
Permissive Counterclaims
The court stated that the analysis required for permissive counterclaims asks
Are there sufficient grounds for federal SMJ? and if not
do the claims meet the test for supplemental jurisdiction under 1367(a)? If no to both, then the claim should be dismissed for lack of Jurisdiction.
Joinder of Parties
Refer to the Post on Joinder of Parties
R. 20 states how a party, either plaintiff or defendant, may join another party if they have a right to relief or if they are jointly and severally liable alongside a defendant.
- a right to relief must be asserted by, or against, each plaintiff or defendant relating to or arising out of the same transaction or occurrence, or series of transactions or occurrences
- All logically related events are considered to be one part of the same transaction or occurrence. Absolute identity of events is not required.
- some question of law or fact common to all the parties must arise in the action.
- The right to relief depends on the ability to determine that the conduct of the defendant is basic to each plaintiff's injury.
Third-Party Claims
Third party claims are ruled by the Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 14.
Third-Party claims are permissive and not compulsory. A party may bring a claim against a third party when the liability of the third party may be dependent upon the outcome of the original action.
Consolidation, Separation, & Severing of Claims
R. 21 states the rule related to misjoinder. R. 42(b) provides the factors to be weighed by the court in exercising the broad discretion to consolidate, separate, or sever claims.
Intervention
Refer to the Post on Intervention
As a Matter of Right
One has a right to intervene if it is granted by a statute OR
Claims an interest relating to the subject of the action that is such that if the action were to be dismissed, it would impair the ability of the movant to protect its interests.
Permissive Intervention
A court may permit intervention on Timely Motion if;
A state statute provides for conditional intervention OR
The movant has an action which shares in a matter of law or fact brought in the original action.
Delay and Prejudice are the factor to be considered by the court when determining whether or not to allow permissive joinder.
Class-Actions
Prerequisites of Class Action: 23(a)
Numerosity, Commonality, Typicality, and Adequacy
the class is so numerous that joinder of all members is impracticable;
there are questions of law or fact common to the class;
- Meaning the class members have suffered the same injury
the claims or defenses of the representative parties are typical of the claims or defenses of the class; and
the representative parties will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the class.
all of these elements must be met.
Types of Classes
23(b)(1) functions similarily to R. 19, and requires that a class be constructed if
Inconsistent adjudication with respect to varying class members would result in absence of the members being treated as a class; or
Not constructing a class would allow for similarly situated parties to not be treated alike.
23(b)(2) allows for class action calling for injunctive relief
- The party opposing the class has acted or refused to act on grounds that apply generally to the class, so that final injunctive relief or corresponding declaratory relief is appropriate respecting the class as a whole.
Rule 23(b)(3) provides that a court can certify such a class only if it meets two criteria in addition to those in 23(a):
That the issues common to the class members predominate over those affecting only individual class members; and
That a class action is superior to any other method for “fairly and efficiently” adjudicating the controversy.